More Texans are struggling to afford healthcare, and state lawmakers want to understand what鈥檚 prompting costs to increase.
Texas House Speaker Dustin Burrows called for the creation of the House Select Committee on Health Care Affordability earlier this year with examining factors that affect healthcare affordability in Texas. In a six-hour day that kicked off a two-day public hearing, lawmakers received a broad overview of the issue before focusing on the role that hospital and drug costs play.
鈥淥ur goal for the committee is to eventually arrive at policy solutions that will help decrease the cost of quality healthcare for our constituents,鈥� said Rep. James Frank, the committee鈥檚 chair. 鈥淎nd, at the very least, stop the out-of-control healthcare inflation that is taking a bigger and bigger piece of every Texan鈥檚 economic lives.鈥�
Frank, who represents House District 69, which includes Wichita Falls and Paducah, said the goal of this hearing isn鈥檛 to discuss policy solutions 鈥� instead he wants policymakers to gather an understanding to inform future conversations.
鈥淢any of us know that healthcare pricing is largely broken,鈥� Frank said. 鈥淏ut I think sometimes it's difficult to know why鈥y truly taking our time, it is also my hope that we can address the root cause of pricing problems as opposed to playing whack-a-mole with the symptoms.鈥�
The committee will return Friday, and will continue to hear invited testimony only. Frank said members of the public who wish to testify can submit written comments to the committee.
Healthcare affordability
Charles Miller, director of health and economic mobility policy at the public policy organization Texas 2036, said health insurance premiums have increased so much that voters are saying it鈥檚 their number one priority 鈥渇or the first time ever.鈥�
鈥淲e launched a voter poll last fall, and this issue was more important than property taxes, than homeowners鈥� insurance, than disaster response, than water infrastructure,鈥� Miller said. 鈥淭hese are all the topics that have been taking up a lot of time at the Capitol, and health affordability is more important to Texas voters than all of them.鈥�
Even as gas prices climb, a recent poll from KFF 鈥� a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that does research on health issues 鈥� showed the cost of of economic concerns for the public.
In the U.S., data shows spending on healthcare is more than in any other large country with a similar sized economy.
Cynthia Cox, senior vice president with KFF, said that doesn鈥檛 result in better health outcomes.
鈥淲e spend almost twice as much on average per person on healthcare,鈥� she said. 鈥淎nd yet, we live shorter lives. And on both of these metrics, the U.S. stands out as being very different from other countries.鈥�
At the same time, the cost of services has increased. Healthcare costs in the , leaving people to pay significant amounts of their paycheck toward health coverage.
Zack Cooper, a professor of public health and economics at Yale University, told lawmakers that since 2000, health care spending in the U.S. has grown three times faster than inflation 鈥� driving 90% of the growth in premiums.
For a family of four, Cooper said the average premiums for employer-sponsored health insurance is about $27,000 annually.
鈥淓very family is basically buying a new Toyota Corolla worth of health insurance,鈥� he said.
Cooper noted rising healthcare costs are one of the leading causes of income inequality in the U.S.
The average family in the U.S. has about $8,000 in 鈥渓iquid assets,鈥� or funds that can be quickly accessed, according to Cooper.
鈥淵ou鈥檙e spending more on health care than you are on your mortgage,鈥� he said. 鈥淚f you get sick, chances are you鈥檙e going to literally go through everything that you have.鈥�
In 2022, spending on hospital of personal healthcare spending for people with private insurance 鈥� like employer-sponsored plans or coverage through the federal health insurance marketplace. That represents the largest portion of healthcare spending 鈥� with physician services accounting for 31% and prescription drugs taking up 23%.
Based on data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Cooper said hospital prices have increased faster than 鈥渧irtually every other sector of the economy.鈥�
High prices not only increase healthcare premiums but tend to drive people away from receiving needed care. While coverage can alleviate some of that cost, Cox said the issue of higher healthcare costs isn鈥檛 solved by expanding the number of people with insurance.
鈥淥f the $200 billion in medical debt that is owed in this country, most of it is owed by people who have health insurance,鈥� she said.
Hospital consolidation
Cooper highlighted the lack or the loss of competition among hospitals as a growing concern that could be increasing prices.
Since 2000, Cooper said there鈥檚 been more than 1,300 mergers among the nation's approximately 5,000 hospitals.
Anthony DiGiorgio, a neurosurgeon and healthcare policy researcher at University of California, San Francisco, said that consolidation contributes to a payment system heavily regulated by third party payers that can create policies 鈥渟o heavy-handed鈥� they shape where care is delivered. Over time, he said those policies have 鈥渟teadily weakened鈥� independent physicians.
鈥淲hen these independent physician practices disappear, patients lose their local options, their direct relationships,鈥� DiGiorgio said. 鈥淚nstead, the patients are directed to these large systems, where the physicians are more loyal to a corporate hierarchy.鈥�
DiGiorgio, who works at a county level hospital, said strong hospitals are necessary for emergency care, teaching, transplant services and safety net functions.
鈥淏ut, patients need a strong independent sector,鈥� he said. 鈥淏ecause it provides patient choice, creates local price competition, and keeps a lot of care closer to home if you live far away from academic centers.鈥�
DiGiorgio said in many cases, doctors don鈥檛 have the ability to benefit from the same programs hospitals do, which can put them at a disadvantage and lead to higher costs for the same services.
In addition, he said regulatory burden prevents physicians from being able to run their own practice. For every one hour that doctors spend with patients, DiGiorgio said studies have shown doctors spend two hours on the computer filling out paperwork.
When a hospital system offers to internalize the bureaucratic processes for doctors, DiGiorgio said that can be paired with the 鈥渟ubsidy streams鈥� that hospitals get, which he says makes saying no 鈥渏ust impossible.鈥�
Drug prices
In addition to concerns about rising drug costs and spending, lawmakers also focused part of the day on pharmacy benefit managers, or PBMs 鈥� companies that act as the 鈥渕iddleman鈥� in the drug supply chain.
鈥淟iterally every state has passed at least one pharmacy benefit manager law,鈥� said Maureen Hensley-Quinn, a senior program director with the National Academy for State Health Policy.
PBMs were created to help insurers control prescription drug spending and manage pharmacy benefits. A PBM will negotiate with drug manufacturers, approve or deny claims and manage drug utilization. It can also determine at which pharmacies people are able to get benefits.
The idea was they would negotiate for better prices and limit unnecessary prescriptions and pass those savings on to the consumer.
However, consolidation and vertical integration have led many experts and policymakers to question what value PBMs offer.
In 2023, the four largest PBMs 鈥� OptumRx, CVS Health, Express Scripts and Prime Therapeutics .
In addition, many experts and policy makers are concerned with 鈥渧ertical integration鈥� in the U.S. drug supply chain 鈥� which refers to when one company owns multiple parts of the supply chain. Vertical integration is typically linked to higher costs for consumers.
For example, CVS Health owns an insurance company, PBM, drug manufacturer, as well as retail and specialty pharmacies and provider clinics.
The vertical integration in the drug space has led state lawmakers across the country to take on PBM reform as a policy issue.
Rep. Trey Wharton, who represents House District 12 north of Houston, said the limited network of pharmacy options can be particularly difficult for people in rural areas.
鈥淪ometimes your insurance plan doesn't have a pharmacy in the small town you live in, so you have to go out of town because it's not covered,鈥� he said. 鈥淭hen, that's also causing the local independent pharmacist to have to sell out, because they can't even buy the drugs as cheap the drug is sold by the big pharmacy.鈥�
Abigail Ruhman is 四虎影院鈥檚 health reporter. Got a tip? Email Abigail at aruhman@kera.org.
四虎影院 is made possible through the generosity of our members. If you find this reporting valuable, consider . Thank you.
